Before you compare retainers, ask one question: what will change on our website if we hire you? A useful answer should name the pages, technical problems, missing information and measurement work the agency intends to tackle. If the answer stays at “more AI visibility,” keep asking.
A B2B company needs the right buyers to understand its capabilities and consider a conversation. An ecommerce business needs shoppers to find suitable products, trust the information and complete a purchase. Those goals overlap, but the work behind them is different.
This guide explains how to evaluate an AI SEO agency, what evidence to request and how to compare proposals. You can also review Elatre’s AI SEO services alongside these criteria.
What should an AI SEO agency actually do?
AI SEO is a practical label for improving how a business can be discovered and understood through search engines and AI-powered answers. The work can include technical access, useful service and product pages, accurate structured data, original evidence and ongoing measurement.
Separate three outcomes in any proposal. A mention names your business. A citation points to a source. A recommendation presents your business as a relevant option. They are different events, and none automatically produces a qualified enquiry or an order.
Ask the agency which of those outcomes it will monitor, how it will repeat the checks and what it will do with the findings. A screenshot of one favourable answer is a starting observation, not a reliable performance report.
What search demand tells us—and what it does not
For this guide, Elatre checked the Semrush US keyword database on 8 October 2026. The estimates below show established search demand around agency services. They help with topic selection and buyer-language research.

| Keyword | Estimated monthly US searches |
|---|---|
| ai seo agency | 3,600 |
| ai seo services | 3,600 |
| generative engine optimization agency | 1,300 |
| answer engine optimization services | 590 |
These are monthly keyword estimates, not the most popular searches in the past 24 hours. They are also not counts of prompts submitted to AI assistants. Related keywords may overlap in audience, so adding the numbers together would not give a unique market size.

The screenshot is an official Semrush Keyword Overview example. Its sample keyword is separate from the research above. When an agency shares research, ask for the country database, the date, the search intent and the actual search results—not just a volume column.
Six questions to ask before signing
1. Which pages would you work on first?
The agency should be able to explain a priority order. For a specialist software company, that might mean a service page, integrations and an implementation guide. For a store, it might mean an important category and its best-stocked products. Publishing volume is not a substitute for choosing the right pages.
2. Who implements the technical changes?
An audit is useful only if somebody can act on it. Clarify who fixes crawling, redirects, canonical tags, internal links and product-data issues. Ask whether implementation is included, requires your developer or will be quoted separately. Name the person responsible for checking that each fix works.
3. How will you learn our business?
Look for a process involving sales questions, product documentation, customer support and subject-matter experts. A writer cannot explain a complex implementation or a product limitation accurately from a keyword list alone. Your team should know which facts it needs to supply and who approves them.
4. What evidence supports your claims?
A useful case study identifies the starting problem, the work completed, the period measured and the source of the result. Ask whether a reported increase refers to impressions, visits, qualified leads or revenue. Those metrics answer different questions. Also ask what else changed during the measurement period.
5. How will you connect visibility with business outcomes?
For B2B, include relevant enquiries, accepted leads and pipeline context where the data is available. For ecommerce, include product visits, orders and conversion context. Referral data and attribution are imperfect; a good report states those limits instead of assigning every unexplained sale to the campaign.
6. What do we own if the engagement ends?
Your agreement should cover website access, content, research, reporting definitions and handover. Ask for a record of completed work and unresolved issues. You should be able to understand what was changed without remaining dependent on one account manager.
Compare the work in the proposals
| Area | What to request |
|---|---|
| Business fit | Priority pages and the buyer questions they answer |
| Implementation | Named owners, dependencies and included technical work |
| Evidence | Dated examples with clearly defined metrics |
| Reporting | Separate visibility, traffic and commercial outcomes |
| Ownership | Access, deliverables and a usable handover |
Worked example: a B2B software buying decision
Illustrative scenario, not an Elatre client result. Consider an inventory-planning software company selling to distributors. One proposal offers twelve generic blog posts a month. Another starts with the pages prospective customers need before booking a demo.
The second proposal finds that the website never explains supported accounting integrations, implementation responsibilities or how pricing is structured. Those omissions matter to a buyer trying to assemble a shortlist. Another general article about efficiency would leave the same questions unanswered.
A sensible initial scope would verify the integration details, rewrite the relevant service pages, add a practical implementation walkthrough and connect those pages with useful internal links. Sales would agree what counts as a qualified demo before reporting begins. The example describes a decision process; it does not claim a traffic or revenue increase.
B2B and ecommerce need different deliverables
A B2B marketing engagement should make capabilities, fit, delivery and evidence easier to assess. Industry pages make sense when the buying requirements genuinely differ. A page for each variation of the same keyword usually adds little for the reader.
An ecommerce engagement should address the catalog, product and category pages, feeds, availability, policies and the route to purchase. Ask how changes will be tested across variants and mobile checkout, particularly when several apps supply product information.
What can an agency reasonably promise?
An agency can commit to defined work, accurate reporting and a review process. It cannot control every assistant response. OpenAI’s search guidance does not offer a way to guarantee placement, and Google’s current guidance connects visibility in its generative search experiences with useful, accessible web content.
Treat a guaranteed recommendation from every model as a claim requiring extraordinary evidence. A more useful commitment is a clear baseline, a prioritised implementation plan and an honest explanation of what the data shows.
Common questions
Do we need a separate agency for AI SEO?
Not necessarily. Evaluate whether your existing team can do the technical, content, product-data and measurement work. A different label does not automatically require a separate supplier.
How should we compare prices?
Compare scope, expertise and implementation responsibility. Ask what the first month produces, what requires an additional budget and how priorities change after the initial findings.
What should we ask for first?
Start with a focused assessment of your important pages, evidence gaps and measurement. It should end with decisions you can act on, not an unexplained score.
Bring a clear brief to the conversation
Tell us who you sell to, which services or products matter most and where discovery or conversion is falling short. Request an Elatre visibility audit to discuss the website work and measurement your business needs.